Most Popular Crime TV Shows — SeasonTracker Tracking Data October 2026
Reacher is tracked by 373 SeasonTracker users this week, making it the most tracked crime show on the platform by a margin of 125 over its nearest competitor. The Lincoln Lawyer sits second with 248, and Paradise rounds out the top three with 211. The figures come from 2,403 SeasonTracker users currently tracking at least one of the 7,813 unique shows in the database, measured for the week of October 12, 2026.
Here is the full top 15 by tracker count:
1. Reacher (Prime Video) | 373 trackers 2. The Lincoln Lawyer (Netflix) | 248 trackers 3. Paradise (Hulu) | 211 trackers 4. Slow Horses (Apple TV) | 201 trackers 5. High Potential (ABC) | 187 trackers 6. Your Friends & Neighbors (Apple TV) | 184 trackers 7. Only Murders in the Building (Hulu) | 178 trackers 8. Tracker (CBS) | 153 trackers 9. Cross (Prime Video) | 127 trackers 10. The Rookie (ABC) | 125 trackers 11. MobLand (Paramount+) | 122 trackers 12. Tulsa King (Paramount+) | 121 trackers 13. Marshals (CBS) | 112 trackers 14. Bad Monkey (Apple TV) | 112 trackers 15. Daredevil: Born Again (Disney+) | 107 trackers
The week-over-week numbers tell a different story than the raw rankings. MobLand added 11 trackers in seven days, the largest weekly gain anywhere in the top 15, despite sitting only eleventh overall. Marshals added 8 and Slow Horses added 7, the second and third fastest movers. Reacher, by contrast, added just 5 trackers week over week, a comparatively small increase for a show carrying the largest audience on this list.
The monthly figures separate steady performers from genuinely accelerating ones. Reacher gained 46 trackers over the past month, the biggest absolute monthly increase in the dataset. MobLand added 39 and Slow Horses added 27. Measured proportionally, MobLand is the standout: its 39 new trackers represent roughly a third of its current total of 122, meaning SeasonTracker users have been adding it at a faster relative rate than any other crime title here.
Several shows are effectively flat. Paradise added nothing week over week and only 2 over the month, holding third place on accumulated interest rather than current momentum. Cross, Bad Monkey, and Daredevil: Born Again all posted zero weekly change, with monthly gains of 6, 4, and 3 respectively. Those are the slowest moving titles in the top 15.
By platform, Apple TV places three shows on the list (Slow Horses, Your Friends & Neighbors, Bad Monkey) for a combined 497 trackers. Prime Video has two titles totalling 500, though Reacher accounts for most of that. CBS, ABC, Hulu, and Paramount+ each place two shows. Netflix places one.
Genre crossover is near universal here. Every show in the top 15 pairs crime with at least one other genre, most often drama. Four titles combine crime with mystery, and three combine it with comedy, including Only Murders in the Building at 178 trackers and Tulsa King at 121. All 15 shows are listed as Returning Series, so none of these counts reflect audiences tracking a concluded run.
Add the shows you are watching to SeasonTracker to follow new episodes and see how your list compares to what everyone else is tracking.