Most Popular Crime TV Shows — SeasonTracker Tracking Data September 2026

Reacher is tracked by 328 SeasonTracker users this week, a lead of 94 over the next crime title on the list. That gap is the widest at the top of any genre ranking we publish, and it is still growing: the Prime Video series added 11 trackers week over week and 38 over the past month, the largest absolute monthly gain among the 15 crime shows below.

The full ranking for the week of September 14, 2026, drawn from 1,801 SeasonTracker users tracking 7,580 unique shows:

1. Reacher (Prime Video), 328 trackers 2. The Lincoln Lawyer (Netflix), 234 trackers 3. Paradise (Hulu), 209 trackers 4. High Potential (ABC), 177 trackers 5. Your Friends & Neighbors (Apple TV), 177 trackers 6. Slow Horses (Apple TV), 174 trackers 7. Only Murders in the Building (Hulu), 167 trackers 8. Tracker (CBS), 141 trackers 9. Cross (Prime Video), 122 trackers 10. The Rookie (ABC), 120 trackers 11. Tulsa King (Paramount+), 113 trackers 12. Bad Monkey (Apple TV), 109 trackers 13. Daredevil: Born Again (Disney+), 105 trackers 14. Marshals (CBS), 100 trackers 15. MobLand (Paramount+), 83 trackers

Amend the em dash note: the list above uses standard separators only.

Most of the week-over-week movement in this category is small, between zero and four trackers, which is typical for a list where every entry is a returning series and none is mid-premiere. Two figures stand out. Reacher's +11 is more than double the next biggest weekly gain. The Lincoln Lawyer, at number two, is flat at 234, the only show on the list with no weekly change at all, and its monthly gain of +5 is among the smallest here despite its high placement. SeasonTracker users are holding onto it rather than adding it.

The monthly column tells a different story than the weekly one. MobLand sits last on the list with 83 trackers but has added 17 over the past month, the second largest monthly gain in the category and by far the largest relative to its base. Tulsa King, the other Paramount+ entry, added 8 over the same period. Tracker on CBS added 12 monthly, Slow Horses 11, and High Potential 10, all steady accumulators rather than weekly spikes.

By network, Apple TV places three shows on the list (Your Friends & Neighbors, Slow Horses, Bad Monkey) with a combined 460 trackers. Prime Video has two, but Reacher and Cross together total 450, most of it concentrated in one title. ABC and CBS each land two entries, and the four broadcast shows average 134.5 trackers, below the streaming average on this list.

Genre overlap is worth noting: 10 of the 15 shows carry a Drama tag alongside Crime, and four combine Crime with Comedy or Mystery-led comedy. SeasonTracker users tracking crime are not tracking procedurals exclusively.

These numbers update as users add and drop titles. Track the shows you are watching on SeasonTracker to keep your own list current and help shape next week's rankings.