Most Popular Reality TV Shows — SeasonTracker Tracking Data October 2026
Two shows are tied at the top of SeasonTracker's reality rankings this week. Clarkson's Farm and The Traitors each sit at 52 trackers as of October 12, 2026, drawn from 2,403 SeasonTracker users who are currently tracking at least one of the 7,813 unique shows in the system.
The tie is the result of different trajectories. Clarkson's Farm added 2 trackers over the past week and 3 over the past month, giving it the only week-over-week gain in the top five. The Traitors was flat week over week but is up 5 on the month, the second largest monthly gain among the top six. Prime Video and NBC therefore split the top spot between them.
Here is the full top 15 by tracker count:
1. Clarkson's Farm (Prime Video), 52 trackers 2. The Traitors (NBC), 52 trackers 3. Survivor (CBS), 47 trackers 4. The Amazing Race (CBS), 37 trackers 5. Welcome to Wrexham (FX), 33 trackers 6. The Great British Bake Off (Channel 4), 29 trackers 7. Mystery at Blind Frog Ranch (Discovery), 27 trackers 8. The Voice (NBC), 27 trackers 9. Dancing with the Stars (ABC), 26 trackers 10. Lock Upp (Netflix), 26 trackers 11. Top Chef (Bravo), 24 trackers 12. Love Is Blind (Netflix), 24 trackers 13. Below Deck Mediterranean (Bravo), 23 trackers 14. Nation's Dumbest (FOX), 22 trackers 15. Beast Games (Prime Video), 22 trackers
The sharpest movement in the table is not at the top. Mystery at Blind Frog Ranch sits seventh with 27 trackers, but it is up 12 on the month, more than double the monthly gain of any other show listed. It also added 1 tracker in the past week, making it one of only three titles in the top 15 with any week-over-week movement at all. On current trends, SeasonTracker users are adding it faster than anything else in the reality category.
The Great British Bake Off is the other notable monthly climber, up 7 to reach 29 trackers in sixth place. Survivor added 4 on the month and The Amazing Race added 3, which keeps the two CBS competition formats stable in third and fourth rather than closing on the leaders. Both were flat this week.
Nation's Dumbest is the only other show with week-over-week movement, adding 2 trackers to reach 22 and a tie for 14th with Beast Games. It is a recent enough addition to SeasonTracker that there is no monthly comparison available yet.
The rest of the table is close to static on a weekly basis, which is typical for established returning series. Welcome to Wrexham, The Voice and Top Chef all registered no change over either the week or the month, holding at 33, 27 and 24 trackers respectively. All 15 shows in this ranking carry a Returning Series status, so none of the counts reflect a cancellation effect.
Bravo places two shows in the table, Top Chef at 24 and Below Deck Mediterranean at 23, with the latter up 2 on the month. Netflix also places two, Lock Upp at 26 and Love Is Blind at 24, each up 1 over the same period.
These numbers update as SeasonTracker users add and drop titles. Track the shows you are watching on SeasonTracker to see where they land in next week's count.